Dent in Fender - Fix or Replace

[bigriver]

A tree branch hit the front right fender on my 2003 EB31. It's an old wound but i want to fix it. There is not a body shop close so thinking might be easier, and less expensive, to replace the fender. I've sourced one in a yard the right color for $75. Looks like R&R shouldn't be too bad in my driveway (as per YouTube anyway). Lookin for ideas about why this might not be a good idea.

Any input appreciated.

[Twoxentrix]

I had my Van at the Dealer recently soliciting a quote on repairing a very very small dent from a branch that fell on mine as well. Initially it chipped the paint from impact, but since the incident the paint has flaked to the size of a quarter.
Dealer quoted $980 to replace the fender and paint both fender & hood. They explained it was essentially same cost to replace the fender as trying to do any bondo repair - the fender was an easy & quick swap. So replacing sounds easy enough, but I'm just sharing what they told me... I have no hands on experience.
I like your scenario better - Sounds like you got lucky scoring a fender with matching color. Hope it polishes up so it blends well.

[bigriver]

I like your scenario better - Sounds like you got lucky scoring a fender with matching color. Hope it polishes up so it blends well.[/QUOTE]

Thanks for the input Two...I guess there are a few advantages to a white van.

[marret]

I say just install the replacement fender as well.

[NavyNuke]

I did a few months ago, took 2 or so hours and a couple beers.

Replaced fender and vallance under the headlights with junkyard parts

[Kibo]

Another vote for replacement. A little more work on the passenger side due to the antenna, but still quite easy.

[bigriver]

That's what I'm goona do then... thanks y'all for the input.