Re: Battery longevity with mild cycling (24/7 Fridge + solar
I have a Victron BMV now, and in past times had a Link. I don't really see how one can be more accurate than another, since it's just a shunt/coulomb counter? I mean, correct me if I'm wrong, as I'm just thinking to myself and can't see how one could be more accurate than another.
(I have to admit though that I can't stand the Trimetric aesthetically, but that's more of a UI thing.)
I think the main area for inaccuracy (which is a biggie) on any coulomb-counter type monitor is that as the battery bank ages and becomes effectively "smaller," unless you adjust for that (and get it right!), the SOC readings become less accurate in the "dangerous" direction (i.e. making things look better than they are). The amps counter should still work correctly though, even without re-adjusting total bank size/capacity, as it's just tallying in and out.
I added a SmartGauge to my "arsenal," and it uses a completely different method to get SOC: I don't totally understand it, but I think it's a combination of super-smart algorithms, and voltage samplings going on thousands of times per second. It does show voltage, but the main reason I have it is to show an accurate SOC (and not need correcting as the bank ages). I also have the Victron, because it is useful too, and does other things such as amps counting.
Yes, it's a bit of cash spent on gauges, but not so hard to rationalize vs. the cost of a bank of AGM's (and I like the information).
|