Quote:
Originally Posted by Ocsmb
Pretty sure mine are warped. Got incredible shudder driving down hill and getting on the brakes. Quite nerve racking. Mines a 2002 btw.
|
FWIW, most "warped rotor" shuddering symptoms are caused by uneven transfer of brake pad friction material from the pad to the rotor, not warped rotors.
Early in my career, I worked at Bendix In South Bend, designing engine controls for military aircraft. The Bendix brake division was next door in the same building; today the aerospace division is part of Honeywell and the brake division is Bosch.
Several of the engineers that I used to work with now work at Bosch developing automotive brake systems, and I've kept in touch with them over the years and every now and then we have the "warped rotor" discussion.
To operate happily, pad material needs to transfer to the rotor surface evenly. That's why it's recommended to properly "bed-in" your brakes after doing a brake job usually by doing a half dozen or so hard stops without coming to a complete stop. If you brake hard and come to a complete stop during bed-in you risk uneven transfer of new pad material to the rotor surface since the new pads will be "cooking" on one small area of the rotor resulting in a varying coefficient of friction on the rotor surface. This is what results in the shuddering during braking.
OEM brake manufacturers have to develop friction compounds for brake pads based on the expected driving habits of the end user, ie granny driving a Buick vs the neighbor kid in his GTI, etc. Most of the time they get it correct and everyone is happy and has smooth and long life braking until they need new pads.
Sometimes, driving habits and pad formulations don't quite line up for example if granny's Buick gets ceramic pads the odds are high that she will not heat up the pads sufficiently to properly transfer pad material to the rotor surface and the neighbor kid with the GTI may burn through OEM pads rather quickly and have other issues like short rotor life.
So brake pad formulations should be selected based on the expected type of driving to be done.
There are many technical papers on this subject around the web if anyone is interested.
http://www.stoptech.com/technical-suppo ... ther-myths
OCSMB: I have a dial indicator and magnetic base if you would like to determine if your rotors are warped. Pop off a wheel, attach the dial indicator and spin the rotor.