Greg, You previously posted
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scalf77
, maybe stepping up to a higher output alternator would be a better solution.
|
In the case of the first comment, an alternator that is burning out is not lacking in amperage capacity, just cooling capacity. That is an operational issue typically associated with low RPM.
So upsizing the alternator will at best increases thermal mass or increase surface area for better heat transfer. For a given DC-DC demand requirement, increasing the output is not what you want nor is it required.
This is what I referred to as brute force. It might help for a while but it is not a very effective means of avoiding burning out the alternator.
I would put the question to you, "if a stock alternator burns out under the DC-DC demand load, how much longer will an upgraded alternator run at the same demand last? Why? The original alternator is not burning out due to lack of amperage, but lack of an ability to cool itself.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scalf77
The simplicity of picking the correct components does also. A properly sized DC to DC charger does not burn up alternators.
-greg
|
In the second quote, you are getting much closer to the issue. The DC to DC needs to be throttled based on the available cooling ability of the alternator. That is primarily a function of load and RPM where at higher RPM the highest loads are supported without thermal runaway issues.
So my point although maybe not stayed very clearly (and I think you are agreeing) is that a direct approach is to moderate the DC to DC demand based on available cooling and even possibly RPM.